Sunday, October 1, 2017

Are Elves stupid in Dungeons & Dragons?

I wanted to call this "Pathfinder Elves are retarded" but that would be too insulting. And I'm not insulting Elves or Dungeons & Dragons. However Elves in D&D 3.5 and Pathfinder have a severe learning disability. The tables are the same in 3.5 Player's handbook, the 3.5 SRD (file: Basic Rules/Description.rtf), and the Pathfinder SRD:
RaceAdulthoodIntuitiveSelf-TaughtTrained
Human15 years+1d4+1d6+2d6
Elf110 years+4d6+6d6+10d6
diff733 1/3 %400-600%600%500%
Half-orc14 years+1d4+1d6+2d6
Based on this the average class modifier is Elf_Age = Human_Age * 5. The adulthood Elf_Age = Human_Age * (7 + 1/3) which could be rounded down to 5 for an adulthood age of 75. You'll notice that half-orcs reach adulthood the fastest and elves the slowest which means that half-orcs learn and mature 7.86 times faster than elves. Despite this some elves gets +2 Int and half-orcs in 3.5 get -2 Int.

Do you have any idea how damaging this slow learning is to the setting? Let's say I'm a human training in wizard school and I meet a stereotypical hot elf girl. We started school at the same time and I don't mind her current age so I make moves on her and start dating. Wizard school is a hard 7 year program that's not uncommon to flunk a few years. My elf lady isn't doing so well in class so I can give her private lessons of things I've already learned or we can practice the same thing together. After 7 years I've been ready for our relationship to advance to the next level for a while now but she's only getting warmed up to the idea of a long term relationship (she doesn't mind that she'll outlive me). I'm about to graduate from wizard school but she's flunked out 6 times and passed one year. I come to find out that the average time it takes an elf to graduate is 35 years! This is consistent with my experience that she's very slow to pick things up and I have to repeat things so many times. She's not an idiot it just takes a long time to learn something new. I simply can't invest that much of my life into someone so slow.

Can you name any other setting where elves are slow at learning magic? And half-orcs are fast at learning anything. It just doesn't fit. It does not make sense to base adulthood on the percent of maximum life. Learning should be based on Int alone and not race at all:
Int ModAdulthoodIntuitiveSelf-TaughtTrained
lessnot possible for player characters, and animals can't take classes
-417 years23 +1d427 +1d635 +2d6
-316 years21 +1d424 +1d630 +2d6
-216 years19 +1d421 +1d625 +2d6
-115 years17 +1d418 +1d620 +2d6
+015 years14 +1d414 +1d614 +2d6
+114 years1514 +1d414 +1d10
+214 years151514 +1d8
+313 years151514 +1d6
+413 years151514 +1d4
more13 years151515
Therefore if you have low intelligence and a short lifespan then you'll be very old by the time you could become a wizard. Note that these are minimum starting ages. You can choose to be older when you start learning but learning still takes time equal to the difference between adulthood and the applicable column.

Now let's look at maximum ages:
RaceMiddle AgeOldVenerableMaximum Age
Human35 years53 years70 years+2d20 years
Elf175 years263 years350 years+4d% years
diff500%496.2264%500%200-1,000%
The average Elf_Age = Human_Age * 5. Why isn't the old elf age 265? Must be a typo that they didn't bother correcting. Also maximum elf age is way too random. How about:
Elf175 years265 years350 years550 +2d% years

Or better yet why not base maximum age on constitution rather than race so that how long you live actually depends on how healthy you are:
Con mod*Middle AgeOldVenerableMaximum Age
lessalready dead (since your constitution score would have to be less than 0)
-515 years25 years45 years50+1d4 years
-420 years30 years50 years55+1d4 years
-325 years35 years55 years60+1d4 years
-230 years40 years60 years65+1d6 years
-135 years45 years65 years70+1d8 years
040 years50 years70 years75+1d10 years
145 years55 years75 years80+1d20 years
250 years60 years80 years85+1d20 years
355 years65 years85 years90+1d20 years
460 years70 years90 years95+1d20 years
more65 years75 years95 years100+1d20 years
*con mod ignoring age penalties
After you have entered an age category, if you raise your con you will be in the same category but the categories above will change.
Elf racial ability: Very Long Life: your age categories except adulthood are multiplied by 5 (this doesn't affect starting ages). You have no Maximum Age.
Half-Elf racial ability: Long Life: your age categories except adulthood are multiplied by 3 (this doesn't affect starting ages).

There's not really any conclusion here. It's just that D&D didn't put much effort into the ages and I actually bothered correcting this.

No comments:

Post a Comment